Correspondence between

Emails where every selected person appears as a sender, recipient, or copied participant.

Governor's statement

Hi Nick and Dan, Senior staff in the Governor’s office has been crafting a communications plan for the next couple weeks concerning the Flint water crisis, and | wanted to keep you in the loop. We’re putting out our summary to media about the OAG’s letter, released today. Gov. Snyder has set up a meeting with Flint Mayor Karen Weaver for next week. And we’re releasing this statement (which still may go through a few more tweaks). It may go out tomorrow, possibly Wednesday: “I’ve been briefed on the recent meeting of the task force studying the Flint water situation and I’ve read the report from the Office of the Auditor General on the processes used by DEQ to monitor Flint water. “The bi-partisan task force is working tirelessly to interview Flint, Genesee County, state and federal officials to complete its independent analysis. They are reviewing hundreds of documents at all levels of government and from the public health science community. “I'd like to thank the task force for keeping me apprised of their continuing investigation. As they uncover more facts, it’s clear to me we can do better. Their report may take another month or so, but if we need to make changes more swiftly, | plan to take immediate action. “No matter what the testing requirements were, they were not enough to prevent this crisis. “When it comes to matters of health and quality of life, we’re committed to doing everything we can to protect the well- being of our citizens. “| understand there can be disagreements within the scientific community. That is why | have told my directors at MDEQ and DHHS to invite every external scientist who has worked on the Flint water issue to the state laboratory facilities to work as partners with us. Together, we should be able to affirm that we’re using the very best testing protocols to ensure Flint residents have safe drinking water and that we’re doing proper monitoring and remediation of blood levels and other health impacts over the long term. “These are only initial steps in our corrective actions. We fully expect to take more actions following the recommendations of our independent task force.” “| want the Flint community and all citizens of Michigan to know how very sorry | am that this has happened. “But | know an apology isn’t enough. We've already allocated $10 million to test the water, distribute water filters, and help in other ways. On Thursday, | called Flint Mayor Karen Weaver, and we’re going to sit down in the next week to discuss other ways the state can offer assistance. “| want to assure residents there that we are working hard to resolve this crisis.” Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions. - Meegan Meegan Holland Director of Communications for Gov. Rick Snyder Office: 517-335-6397 Mobile Twitter: @meholland xxxEND_PAGE:deq19_b01_0001_0036_30

RE: Comments on SoS

Dan, Thanks for putting this draft together. | agree with Rich's edits, and the attached document has my recommendations. Also, | suggest we add the following departments to comment on this document as the issue in Flint now goes beyond water quality: Treasury, MSP and Dept. of Education. I've taken the liberty to solicit comments from the added directors through this reply. Best, Harvey ~——Original Message-----

Comments on SoS

Dan: l added Jarrod and Meegan since we were engaged with Harvey and with Governor Thursday morning last week. | may be advocating a higher degree of "aggression" than others deem proper and | will defer to Jarrod after having had my say. My key points on the attached (with suggested language and which have been highlighted) are: 1). Apologize. it happened on our watch and it shouldn't have happened, no matter what the law says. 2). Invite those who were the biggest burrs under the saddle to come work with us. In fact, we should be articulating how they have already been invited to our labs to collaborate on the findings and conclusions. 3). Start framing the infrastructure problem. We have huge problems throughout the state with aged piping and plumbing. Ignoring it will be at the peril of future generations. We should put a number out there on what it is going to take to fix it or conclude it is safe for generations to come. Thanks for taking the lead. Regards, xxxEND_PAGE:treasury01_b26_3730_4111_204 Rich xxxEND_PAGE:treasury01_b26_3730_4111_205 J have put in []... Draft -Not for Distribution 12/28/15 TAKING ACTION ON FLINT WATER (would start off with an apology..."Among the things our citizens have a right to expect from their government Is clean, safe water. In Flint's case, government failed them on many levels. As the Chief Executive of the state, | apologize for these failures and am absolutely committed to making things right. | would ask that all of our leaders at the local, state and federal level, work with me to solve the immediate problems and put in place long term measures to manitor and address the consequences from exposure. | also want to thank Dr. Mona Attisha Hannah and Dr. Mare Edwards for their diligence in making sure | understood the severity of the problem before us.] . Every municipatity in Michigan deserves safe drinking waters Commented [HH4}: The Issue in Flint is the tallure of Government to ensure safe drinking water. The aging infrastructure exacerbated that fallure, and serves as the canary in the coal mine re the need for the legitinture to address water and sewage infrastructure statewhdte. * As Governor, | am committed to addressing the issue. * Lead exposure is a serious issue. * lappreciate those who have brought attention to this issue. © We are committed to safe drinking water and to working in partnership with the city of Flint, Genesee County, and the U.S. EPA. * We must learn from what happened in Flint. In October, | announced a ten point action plan to address lead exposure in Flint. * Today, | am outlining additional actions to make sure the public health is protected in Flint and elsewhere in the State of Michigan. © 1am asking for changes in order to see that the Michigan Drinking Water Program becomes a national leader in public health protection. On October 2, 2015 the Flint Water Action Plan was announced. With the help of the Michigan Legislature and the Mott Foundation, we have taken significant action to address the issue. Actions include: © Switching back to the Great Lakes Water Authority/DWSD water supply (October 16, 2015) ‘Commented (HM2}: [tis impartent to nate that this switch Is temporary until KWA Is online, xxxEND_PAGE:treasury01_b26_3730_4111_206 © Provided water filters to residents of Flint. (DHHS to provide update) [Distribution has been a problem--are we addressing it?] © Testing all Flint schools, preschools and day cares. Summary of results to date.(George to provide) Expanded health exposure testing of individual residences. Summary of results to date. {Nick to provide) © Offer water testing at no cost to Flint residents to assure safe water. Summary of results to date. (George to provide) © Expedite optimizing corroston control in the Flint drinking water system. Summary of date completed. (George to summarize) © Utilize the “Safe Drinking Water Technical Advisory Committee.” To ensure the best technology, practices and science are being utilized; national experts have been assembled to provide technical advice. [Will you include Dr. Mona? Larry Reynolds? Mark Edwards?) Accelerate water system improvement to address replacement of tead service lines. We are working with the city of Flint and our Congressional delegation on a lead service line replacement plan. * Working to expedite the completion of the Karegnondi Water Authority._And to provide the ex e rade the water treatment facility in Flint to ensure that the drinking water from (A is at least th juality as the water from GLWA/DWSD ¢ Expand a lead education program. (DHHS to provide update) * Dr. Eden Wells was named as the Flint Drinking Water Public Health Advisor to ensure safe drinking water. [Flint’s Head of Mott Children’s Hospital, Dr. Larry Reynolds was named to the Flint After Action Task Force]. In addition to the announced Flint Action plan, | am calling for additional actions to be taken. ¢ Recently appointed Harvey Hollins to serve as my administration’s point person to coordinate ongoing activities and partner with the city of Flint. [Harvey will be supported by senior members of my executive team to remove impediments and ensure efficient coordination at all levels.) xxxEND_PAGE:treasury01_b26_3730_4111_207 * Asking the DEQ to develop a statewide drinking water school testing program. * Asking for changes in the Michigan Drinking Water Program In order for it to be recognized as a national leader in public health including: o New administrative leadership. 0 Creation of corrosion control expertise. o Expanded statewide testing. 0 Improved testing protocols. ® The creation of a health fund for children affected by lead exposure. * Calling on the Legislature to work with my administration and stakeholders to develop a Strategic Water Fund to address Michigan’s long term safe water and water quality Infrastructure needs. [This can't get lost. Need more to educate people that our infrastructure is old, that the average city of 50,000 or more likely requires $$$ in remediation. At some point the anti corrosive treatment Is not likely to be sufficient. © | will look to implement additional recommendations of the Flint Water Advisory Task Force, and | appreciate their leadership on this issue. [1 would say more here—the TF was bi-partisan, Independent, and staffed by incredible talent. it has done an incredible Job]. ¢ Ensure transparency for the public regarding actions taken in Flint to resolve this crisis Sent from my iPad

Fwd: Flint Briefing 9Dec15

<[email protected]>, “Becker, Timothy (DHHS)" <[email protected]>, “Bruneau, Michelle Van Dam, Paula (DHHS)}" <Kaiser? @rnichigan.gov>, “Lasher, Geralyn (DHHS}" <lasherg @ michigan. gov>, “Lyon, Nick (DHHS}" <LyonN2 @michigan.gov>, “McKane, Patricia (DHHS)" <McKaneP @michigan.gov>, Sandip (DHHS)" <[email protected]>, "Sims, Teri (DHHS) <[email protected], "Stanbury, Martha (DHHS)” "Stiffler, Kathleen A, (DHHS)" <StifflerkK @michigan.gov>, “Taylor, Kerri (BHHS)" "Thompson, Sheryl D. (DHHS)" <Thompson$2 @michigan.gov>, “Titus, Laura (DHHS}" <[email protected]>, "Travis, Rashmi (DHHS)"

Fwd: Flint Briefing 9Dec15

Dan - Here is the latest from DHHS. xxxEND_PAGE:deq24_b233_0578_0579_1 Begin forwarded message: gOv>, "Grijalva, flaney (HH >, "Groetsch, Kory J. (DHHS)" SGloetseh pian Fr REN? ? "Harvey, Janice (DHHS)" ‘ igan.goy>, "Lasher, Geralys (DHHS)" asove, "Lyon, Nick (OH) ALB ON>, McKane, Patricia (DHHS)" < an F “Miller, eS a ere: shigan.gov>, “Miller, Mark (OHS) y >, "Minicuci, Angela (DHHS)" <iéini i “higan.gov>, "Peeler, Maney: (DUES) (>, "Priem, Wesley F. (DHHS)" <pri ; fastlia@m av>, "Ridley, Nancy (DHHS)" >, "Robinson, Mikelle Diss)” ery’ (D HS)" <Re ket : Se >, "Shah, Sandip (DHHS)" <3 (DHHS) an.gev>, "Stanbury, Martha (DHHS) <staniburym! higan.gov>, “sutflers: Kathleen A. (DHHS)" <: "Taylor, Kerri (DHHS) I>, “Thompson, Sheryl D. (DHHS) <Themasons? higan "Travis, Rashmi (DHHS)" <} <ig

Filter distribution data

gouencentar MDHHS purchased total water filter distribution 10/6-10/9 = 473% Tuesday ape filters were distributed through MDHHS offices, GCCARD the local Community Action Agency, Flint Housing Commission, Early Head Start, Mott Park Neighborhood Association and Commissioners. Wednesday 1 Age filters were distributed through MDHHS offices and GCCARD. GCCARD is coordinating filter installations for seniors and home bound individuals. The UAW pipe fitters are donating in kind services of $20,000 for this installation. United Way has given filters to homeless shelters and any undocumented immigrants that have come to the Center. Filters were delivered to several senior housing complexes for maintenance to install. Thursday 1046 filters were distributed through MDHHS offices and GCCARD. MDHHS is also working to inform licensed non-school based daycares on where to get water filters. Friday 635 Filters were distributed through MDHHS offices and GCCARD. 24 water pitchers were distributed as well xxxEND_PAGE:executiveofficeemails20_b0500_1721_1721_1

Fwd: - annotated - flattened.pdf

Hi all - attached are the Gov's edits to the order of items in the action plan. I know we had a robust discussion about these today and everyone felt pretty deliberative and flowed, but please review and let us know if anyone has any major heartburn. Otherwise, this is what will go with and change news release to match. TPs can probably stay in order originally for press conference to maintain flow of Dan, Nick, et al. These have to be to printer by 7 am tomorrow am in order to get done in time for press conference. Thx much, SW Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: - annotated - flattened.pdf xxxEND_PAGE:deq24_b394_0978_0978_1

Fwd: Flint drinking water

Hello Dan: Attached please find our emergency SDWA petition to U.S. EPA regarding the Flint situation. Here’s a link to the release: Henry Henderson, NRDC’s Midwest Director is the person to contact about this. He’s at [email protected] and is cc’d here. Rebecca Stanfield Deputy Director Midwest Program Natural Resources Defense Council 20 N. Wacker Drive, Suite 1600 Chicago, IL 60606 T 312.651.7910 M 773.454.0155 rsianfield @nric.are NREC Please save paper. Think before printing. xxxEND_PAGE:deq24_b110_0283_0283_1

Kildee Letter DRAFT

Importance: High Nick & Dan: Please take a look at the attached draft letter to Congressman Kildee, particularly the 4 requests for federal action. Please edit/add as necessary. Thanks for your quick attention to this — we need to have this ready for the Governor’s signature by 8:30am tomorrow. Sorry for the tight turnaround. --Eric Eric K Brown Senior Federal Policy Representative State of Michigan — Governor Rick Snyder ester D.C. Office xxxEND_PAGE:deq21_b445_1228_1229_2

Showing 1-25 of 31