Correspondence between

Emails where every selected person appears as a sender, recipient, or copied participant.

Re: The requested file has been sent

Thanks bob. So it's not possible to get the real values (with decimals)? What about levels of "undetectable" - what are they converted to? Mona Hanna-Attisha MD MPH FAAP Director, Pediatric Residency Program Hurley Children's Hospital Michigan State University gov> wrote: Mona, The integers in your file are the values we have stored in our blood lead surveillance system; that's our current protocol. To my knowledge, the CDC's Lead program has not taken a stance on whether to store decimals or not. Bob

RE: The requested file has been sent

You are correct that lead level results in the file you received are rounded (i.2., no decirnal places}. The data set we are using in epidemiology (which is the sare type of file Mr. Scott would have xxxEND_PAGE:dhhs02_b1012_3602_3604_1 003603 pulled from the data warehouse for you) contains values from 4 to 49. Ara you seeing the 10 and above levels? ido not know the rounding rules for the lead result data and am still working on getting you that information.

RE: The requested file has been sent

Follow Up Flag: Flag for follow up Flag Status: Completed Dr. Hanna-Attisha, | got your email and am working on an answer for you. Sarah Sarah Lyon-Callo, MA, MS Director, Lifecourse Epidemiology and Genomics Division Bureau of Disease Control, Prevention and Epidemiology Population Health and Commmunity Services Administration Michigan Department of Health and Human Services 201 Townsend St., 4" Floor Capitol View Building PO Box 30195 Lansing, MI 48909 PH: 517-335-9315 This message, including any attachments, is intended solely for the use of the named recipient(s) and may contain confidential and/or privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure, or distribution of any confidential and/or privileged information contained in this e-mail is expressly prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy any and all copies of the original message. Please note: Michigan has a public records law. Mast written cornmunicatians to or from state officials regarding state business are public records available ta the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communications and any attachments to therm may be subject te public disclosure.

RE: The requested file has been sent

fluick question: We have the data and ara starting to georode it! All of your lead level results are single rumbers with no decimais?? It’s kinda weird. Al af aur lab data included decimals and there was aise kids with <0.5 levais {undetectable}. xxxEND_PAGE:dhhs02_b1011_3599_3601_1 003600 Does your lead data just not have decimals? Do nurnbers get round up or round down? Thanks! Mona {ido understand that it’s Friday. Sorry} Viena Hanne-Attisha MD MPH FAAP Prograrn Director Pediatric Residency Hurley Chil "s Hospital fey Medic University College: ent of Fediatrics and Murnan | [email protected] <irnapedOd jog>

RE: The requested file has been sent

Chick question: We have the data and are starting to geocada it! AH of your lead level results are single numbers with no decimals? ? {t's kinda weird. AH of our lab date included decirnais and there was also kids with <0.5 levels (undatectabla}. 1 xxxEND_PAGE:dhhs03_b0755_2621_2623_1 002622 Does your lead data just not have decimais? Do nurnbers get round up or round down? Thanks! Mona {ido understand that it’s Friday. Sorry Viena Hanne-Sttisha MD MPH FAAP Prograrn Director Pediatr ancy gan State University College of riment of Pediatrics and Murna Mhannai @hurleyme.caom

RE: The requested file has been sent

Importance: High Good afternoon, Mona - Today is Bob's scheduled day off. He carne in to prepare and send the file, but has left far the rest of the day. Iwill see f ican reach him to find out what step to teke te get you access to the data. Can you give me any more detail that | can share with him, if ican reach him? it sounds Hke you did receive the arnail with the file attached, and the passward U assume via fax}. if those two pleces are in place, Is the issue that it wan't ‘unzip’? Nancy Peeler, Manager Early Childhood Health Section

RE: MDHHS IRB Approval - 201509-11-EA

Mona, I’m authorized to provide you with the file at 1:30 this afternoon. It can be delivered either of two ways: 1) | can post it to our secure FTP site on Michigan’s Single Sign-On page. That's our usual method, but it would require a couple of minutes of your time to get signed up. | can send instructions in you wish. 2) I can send it by email as a zipped and encrypted attachment. You’d need WinZip and the password to unzip it. | could send the password to a fax number if you provide one. Please let me know which you'd prefer. A few words about the file: It has 18,688 records, all blood lead results currently in our system for children less than five years of age at time of test, with address listed as Genesee County, with specimen date from 1/1/2013 to 9/15/2015. The fields are Child 1D (unique to each child}, date of birth, specimen date, house number, street name, patient city, patient zip code, pb result, sample type (V-venous, C-capillary or blank-unknown), gender code (M, F, or blank}, county, and serial number (a unique ID for each record). : The file format is tab-delimited text. I think that’s everything, but if you have questions after reviewing the file, please let me know. Bob Robert L. Scott Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Program Michigan Department of Health & Human Services (517) 335-8178 fax (517) 335-8509 xxxEND_PAGE:dhhs02_b0942_3364_3430_52 003416

Re: State data - Dr. Mona Hanna-Attisha

Bob, Do you have a time estimate on when we will receive the data? The first time | asked our county health dept for this data was Aug 27 and they eventually realized they didn't have the ability to pull such data and then the first time | asked you for the data was mid September. | recognize this has nothing to do with you, but it's been a bit frustrating. Just hoping for a quick turn around. xxxEND_PAGE:dhhs02_b0942_3364_3430_07 003371 Thanks. Mona Hanna-Attisha MD MPH FAAP Director, Pediatric Residency Program Hurley Children's Hospital Michigan State University

RE: State data - Dr. Mona Hanna-Attisha

Jenny, As long as this request is for “research,” then i don't think it will be a problem to provide addresses. You're correct, it would then be considered “identifiable.” One thing that might slow it down--/ believe you’d have to go back to Hurlay’s IRB and get approval for the change. Bob Sent: Friday, September 25, 2015 ki es PM

State data - Dr. Mona Hanna-Attisha

Hi Bob, My name is Jenny LaChance, and I have been working with Mona on the data. We are now doing in depth GIS analysis, which involves actual address (beyond zipcode), Would adding actual address slow down the request for the State data? I believe this would not longer be a limited data set. Any advice or guidance would be truly appreciated. Thank you so much! Jenny xxxEND_PAGE:dhhs02_b0942_3364_3430_09 003373 DATA USE AND NON-DISCLOSURE AGREEMENT CONCERNING PROTECTED HEALTH INFORMATION OR OTHER CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION Michigan Department of Health and Human Services Project Title: Analysis of Pediatric Blood Lead Levels in Flint, Ml Data Recipient: Mona Hanna-Attisha, MD MPH and co investigators Jenny LaChance MS and Richard Sadler PhD Organization: Hurley Medical Center Address: One Hurley Plaza Flint, Mi 48503 Phone: 810-262-7257 e-mail: [email protected] In accordance with this agreement, data are provided by the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services (MDHHS), Family, Maternal and Child Health/Family and Community Health on September/October 2015 to the Data Recipient. The parties agree to the provisions specified in this Agreement, the Health insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), and all other applicable public health, research, and confidentiality laws. What is the Source of the Requested Data? (e.g., Vital Records, Health Statistics, Cancer Surveillance, Medicaid, etc.) MDHHS Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Program database What is the Data Recipient's Purpose for, and Specific Use of, the Data? 4. Describe why these data are requested (e.g., Research, Statistics, Public Health, Health Care Operations, Administration of the Medicaid Program). These data are being requested for two reasons: the primary purpose is related to public health. We are looking at the impact so that measures can be implemented to address any increase in children with elevated blood levels. The data is also being for research purposes so our findings can be shared with other communities. 2. Describe how the data will be used/disclased, or incorporate by reference and attach a copy of the research protocol, work plan, or request letter that details the purpose and use of data, etc. Data for SPSS will be deidentified once 1) one value per person has been selected, 2) whether or not they live in the higher risk part of Flint for lead has been coded, and 3) the timing of when they had their lead level (pre/post) has been determined. GIS analysis will use address but will not include any other PHI identifiers. Data will saved only on encrypted zip drives or secure hospital computers located in personal office of one of the researchers. Only the 3 researchers directly involved with study will have any access to data. Encrypted zip drives will be kept secure with a researcher or in a locked office at all times. Once identifiable data is not needed, files with identifiable information will be destroyed. 3. Describe the data requested indicating amount, type, by what medium the data will be provided, and whether the data recipient is granted access to the data warehouse or state archives. Data Overview Description a. Specify the data elements (e.g., age, gender, etc.) and time periods (e.g., January 2003 through January 2006). Time period: January 2013 through Sept 15,2015; Data Elements: Child ID number, date of birth, date of blood draw, address with zip code, blood lead level, and specimen type. Gender, race and insurnace type are also requested if available. b. — Specify if the data requested is identifiable, de-identified, or a limited data set as defined by HIPAA. identifiable since addresses are being requested for GIS analysis DCH-1294 (05/15) Page 1 of 5 xxxEND_PAGE:dhhs02_b0942_3364_3430_10 003374 c. Speaify the medium requested .G, elecisonic, hard capy, ete.). eleotronic d. Spacify if direot access to the data wardirouse or state archives is requested. Not unless necessary for this request of data BOHH4204 (GB/t5) Page 2 of 5 xxxEND_PAGE:dhhs02_b0942_3364_3430_11 003375 Research Project: Complete this box if requested data will be used for human subjects research. Is Institutional Review Board (IRB) (human subjects research) approval required? i] YES LINo If YES, MDHHS Approval Number... cece cece Approval Number (Attach MDHHS Approval Form) Is HIPAA Informed Consent/Authorization Waiver Required? KX] YES LINO lf YES, MDHHS Approval Number (if above IRB approval not required)... eee Approval Number (Attach HIPAA Waiver Authorization, if relevant.) With regard to data provided under this agreement, the Data Recipient agrees to: 4. Use and disclose the data only in accordance with this agreement, or as otherwise required by law; 2. Limit access to these data only to those described and authorized in this agreement; (MDHHS may require the specific identification of the person(s) or the agency/division/office that is permitted access. {dentify if needed.) 3. Use appropriate safeguards to prevent use or disclosure of the information other than as provided by this agreement; (MDHHS sponsor may require description of the security procedures that will be in place and followed.) Data will be kept very secure through the use of encrypted thumb drives (or on hospital secure computers in individual researchers’ offices) and only seen by 3 researchers. Data will be with one of the researchers or in a Jocked office at all times. Identifiers will be removed for files for analysis as not needed and all identifiable data destroyed once not needed. As soon as data files and analysis are completed, fites with identifiers will be destroyed. For GiS analysis, data and analysis file with address will be kept until after all work on data is complete, including dissemination and time for peer response. 4. Report to the responsible MDHHS sponsor any use or disclosure of information that is not provided for by this data use agreement; 5. Ensure that any agent(s) or subcontractor(s) who access these data agree to the same restrictions and conditions that apply to the data recipient; (MOHHS sponsor may stipulate that release of data to a subcontractor cannot be done without the written authorization of MDHHS.) 6. Make no attempt to identify or contact the individuals, providers, or health plans within the data provided unless approved in this agreement; (Describe any agreed upon exceptions if needed.) 7. Data recipient must provide MDHHS at least thirty days to review and provide comments on papers, publications, or presentations that the data recipient plans to submit for publication or presentation. Data recipient agrees that it will not publish or disseminate any protected heaith information, personally identifiable information, or data that might make it possible, directly or indirectly, to identify an individual. Data recipient must acknowledge the MDHHS program as appropriate (e.g., source of data, etc.), assume full responsibility for the analysis and interpretation of the data, and provide a copy of the publication or presentation to MDHHS. To the extent data recipient requires technical assistance in analyzing or interpreting the data and when such assistance goes beyond providing non-manipulated data, MDHHS reserves the right to request that these activities be considered a substantial contribution to the research being conducted and that the provision of such assistance may warrant MDHHS be considered as a research collaborator or co-author in any resulting publications or presentations; 8. Return or destroy all originals and copies of any potentially identifiable information upon completion of project, or upon request, unless otherwise approved in this agreement. This includes, but is not limited to: magnetic tape, micro disk files, paper records, etc. If not returned to the MOHHS, then the data must be destroyed; e.g., use a CD/DVD shredder to destroy CD Roms, DVDs, efc., erase floppy/zip disks using a magnet, shred paper records, clean computer hard drives with a program designed to wipe a disk by overwriting, etc.; 9. Not use the data provided to engage in any method, act, or practice which constitutes a commercial solicitation or advertisement of goods, services, or real estate to consumers; and 10. Not use the data provided as a basis for legal, administrative or other actions which may affect particular individuals or establishments as a result of their specific identification in this project. DCH-1294 (05/18) Page 3 of 5 xxxEND_PAGE:dhhs02_b0942_3364_3430_12 003376 The MDHHS may cancel this agreement with proper netite. Tire unauitirsitezed use or disetesere ef confidential information is punishable by imprisenneent er fine er beth under state anid fetteral laws specific to the data released. DEHHAF204 (BRATS) Page 4 of 5 xxxEND_PAGE:dhhs02_b0942_3364_3430_13 003377 |, the data recipient, have read, understand, and agree to the above conditions. DATA RECIPIENT SIGNATURE: Mona Hanna-Attisha, MD, MPH Director, Pediatric Residency Program, Hurley Children's Hospital Name of Responsible Data Recipient (Type or Print) Title Signature of Responsible Data Recipient Date MDHHS SIGNATURES: MDHHS SPONSOR Robert L. Scott Departmental Specialist Name of Responsible MDHHS Sponsor (Type or Print} Title Signature of Responsible MDHHS Sponsor Date MDHHS RESPONSIBLE PARTY Brenda Fink, A.C.S.W. Director, Division of Family and Community Health Name of MOHHS Director, Bureau Director, or Delegated Authority (Type or Print) Title Signature of MOHHS Director, Bureau Director, or Delegated Authority Date AUTHORITY: This form is acceptable to the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services as compliant with : HIPAA privacy regulations, 45 CFR Parts 160 and 164 as amended, COMPLETION: Is required if disclosure is requested. The Michigan Department of Heaith and Human Services is an equal opportunity employer, services, and programs provider. DCH-1294 (05/15) Page 6 of 5 xxxEND_PAGE:dhhs02_b0942_3364_3430_14 003378 Peeler, Nancy (DHHS)

RE: Automatic reply: New DCH-1294, time-sensitive

Morne, when you get the data let me know. Since you are involved and have apparently requested the data already {independently}, { wil net be bothering Robert further. However, | will be speaking out, about the unethical behavior af the state in not sharing the data to date, and their abusing of power to discredit the work you have core. The second thay give you the data t will stop speaking aut. Robert, | apologize to you because i know you did not have anything to do with it, but what is happening here Is just wrong, Best Regards, Mare

RE: Automatic reply: New DCH-1294, time-sensitive

Mona, There’s generally alag of about two weeks from the date of the test to its being fully processed in our system. A few results take longer, for a variety of reasons. 99% of all results through August should be reflected in thase numbers. Not sure why the last few months were so flow. Thanks, Bob

Showing 1-25 of 37