Ryan Felton

Freelance Reporter at Reuters / Reporter

25

Emails

Aug 2014–Feb 2016

Archive range

25 emails found.

Questions for story

Hi Terry and David, I'm working on a story about the negotiations between Flint and Detroit in 2013 and 2014. I had some questions for the both of you: -- According to a letter sent in February 2014 by DWSD to Flint’s EM, the utility "to date" had received no official confirmation on Flint's plans for a water source, despite months of negotiations, This has been explained to me as an attempt to confirm what Flint actually planned to do after its 1965 contract with DWSD expired in April 2014 - and to either to strike a short- term deal until the KWA was online, or strike a new long-term deal with Detroit. As it was explained to me, DWSD was essentially still "in the dark" about the city's plans at this point. The governor's timeline says Flint made the decision to use the river in June 2013, Can you explain what that means, and how that decision was made? Was that decision ever officially conveyed to DWSD? Why or why not? -- Despite the commitment of Flint and Genesee County to use a new system, negotiations were clearly still ongoing until a final letter was sent by Darnell Earley in March 2014 to DWSD, saying the city's plan was to use the river. Discussions over regionalizing DWSD were ongoing at the time. Do you have any comment on why DWSD was "left in the dark" about Flint and Genesee's plan going forward, even though it represented a substantial customer base for the system? -- Emails released this week indicate DWSD offered a nearly 50% discount to Flint in April 2014 to stay with Detroit. That deal was ultimately rejected by Flint's emergency manager. As you've explained to me previously, Treasury was aware of the negotiations. Did this deal ever come across then-Treasurer Dillon's desk? If so, why was it rejected? xxxEND_PAGE:treasury01_b38_6783_6976_046 And the decision to use the KWA was painted as a cost-cutting measure. If DWSD's estimates of $800m in savings over 30 years is accurate, is that still an accurate description? I appreciate your time and look forward to your response. Best, Ryan Felton Journalist Detroit, MI 734.353.2221 ryancfelton.com Twitter: @ryanfelton13 xxxEND_PAGE:treasury01_b38_6783_6976_047 Stanton, Terry A. (T reasury)

RE: PRESS INQUIRY| The Guardian

To
Unknown recipient
> > Hi all, > > | had a question regarding the emails that were released this evening. With regards to the attached email, what exactly is Muchmore referencing when he says Dillon made the “ultimate decision"? The decision for the city to use the Flint River or for it to use the KWA? > > I'd appreciate a reply at your earliest convenience. > > Thanks much, > Ryan > > <Image-1.jpg> > > > > Sent from my iPhone xxxEND_PAGE:treasury01_b41_7622_7971_021 auaudl Aw w013 3 “Oauy 08 G3 jue 4} UGAG DUE Queda, ULM a2ej Of ae; Jo duysig e 7nd UES aM PLE BU DUEISJapUA IRCA WaWUB[ddNs WED aA LEYR Ofuy je © SATY SA2g PUP POUT YyNIs YIM NeA PooY O02 JEN },UOP | GS Sty [8 Ud paau NEA pune Yan MOY BINS TOU IOEINPS Ue se aaly NO SHG Sund ypeodde aagoe-oud e TupyEy a,am wasp 4)3ij) PUB S187/9 yo YlesY aly s] aay snes] ai] @Iu15 ING “YAAY PUe AyD “AQUTOD aLp yap sysau Amyqisuodsas jeas PafqNs ayy pjoae oy ayqe JOU ay,aM OS OS] SEWN SQ SYeW PIP UO}IG Tus Idsoxe ajqusuodsas 3] aYEIS ar Aym INO asnFy y,ued) “AYqSUadsa! TuRINp 3 & SUR PUY TAREE Tey Wey ysl (py 3) ANY UTA jC} up ned gr ng ‘Apygnd yf asn 6} aus say amnerag Ayan SEU * iPM [29 © 109 SUNSe S| aapYy “UOlsPap BUY ay) Uj waWAA;OAUI s,uO]C pue AssanoQua GSyia/eAWy aus Bue ‘Uap days pue siogydisu papeduy aij jo asnesag ans syuQ OY] JOYA Pue aw Jo JUROWeE aqipasayy ue ind aney “ARETS Buy 0} Ac suOdsas Yyyys 0) Buy Ayeinoqued pue sucpcinded 6yy uo syacdiu) ays Suyewpisase| ai2 USUIedap ayy Au)WeP (j2q 709; [EIYO & OpU! 1) WIN) OF BuyAy pure pea] oO} amsodxe suolpyiy jo a annisuas Aran ayy Jue) ase WI] 4 Ul} eusoS JOUR [Bay HIG pue OIg SsuL ‘UaqUa}UOD pue AsJaAONQUOD 3yy Jo SOLU pau SSL ADPOU JANE TU 4 Ss OY JAAD YSN alyL “1do) Ruisuayeys e aq 04 sanuyuUEa Aqenb s}) pue Ja}ErA W]4 JO ANSS. S232 Jury af <Aot undnpwapuasy> (AOD) pouers ‘uady laos ued yaw) ZLENOIs> (ANS) UOsIy WOI5 OD) uc ‘4311: (009) 11 ‘sepAus INU GZ-O8 SLOz ‘Sz Jaquiagdas ‘Aepy 33 (A095) siuuag ‘uounpnyy cw -———-oiessalal (EUG: xxxEND_PAGE:treasury01_b41_7622_7971_022 Workman, Wayne (TREASURY)

Re: PRESS INQUIRY | The Guardian re: Flint River

To
Unknown recipient
Sorry, forgot to add this one: Howard Croft, Flint's then-director of the city's Public Works Department, is on the record as saying the decision to use the Flint River came from the governor's office; that "evaluations [went] all the way up to the state level on what the best course of action would be for the city of Flint, and that was the determination." So, based on what you just told me, would you say that Croft's statement is false? Did the state Treasury have to approve this, as the city was under a financial emergency? Thanks much! Ryan xxxEND_PAGE:treasury01_b40_7317_7621_165 On Thu, Jan 14, 2016 at 4:49 PM, Ryan Felton <Q omail.com>

Re: PRESS INQUIRY | The Guardian re: Flint River

To
Unknown recipient
Hi Terry, I spoke with David Murray and he said this is a question that would be best suited for you. I'm on a tight deadline, so I'd be truly grateful for a response at your earliest convenience. Per the Auditor General's report on Flint - after it says that DWSD sent a one- year notice that it would terminate its agreement to provide water service on April 17, 2014: “According to DEQ management, the Flint WTP attempted to negotiate with the DWSD to maintain it as the City of Flint water supplier, however, after negotiations were unsuccessful, the City of Flint notified DEQ through a permit request of its intent to operate the Flint WTP full time using the Flint River. Although the Flint City Council voted in March 2013 in support of moving to the K WA pipeline, the vote was silent on the use of the Flint River as a temporary drinking water source." So, my questions are: 1. Since City Council did not vote on the use of the Flint River as a temporary drinking water source, who handled the negotiations with DWSD ou behalf of Flint that were eventually “unsuccessful,” as it's described in the auditor general's letter. 2. Was the governor's office involved in those negotiations? Was the governor involved? Let me be clear: I understand that, after negotiations fell through, it was decided to use the backup water supply. I appreciate your time and look forward to your response. Best, xxxEND_PAGE:treasury01_b40_7317_7621_166 Workman, Wayne (TREASURY)

Re: PRESS INQUIRY | The Guardian re: Flint River

To
Unknown recipient
Thanks, Terry. And is there a known date as to when negotiations fell through? As far as I can tell, in late July, it was still reported that negotiations were ongoing. On Thu, Jan 14, 2016 at 4:47 PM, Stanton, Terry A. (Treasury)

Re: FOIA REQUEST

To
Deqfoia
Due! /0O-27-1S5— Apologies for not including it at first, Rose. It is: 1326 Bagley St., Apt. 2F, Detroit, MI 48226.

FOIA REQUEST

To
Deqfoia
xxxEND_PAGE:deq04_b015_0647_0780_001 Please find attached a FOIA request dated Oct. 5, 2015. Let me know if you have any trouble opening the file. Thanks much, Ryan Felton Journalist Detroit, MI 734.353.2221 ryanfelton.tumblr.com Twitter: @ryanfelton13 Ryan Felton Journalist Detroit, MI 734.353.2221 ryanfelton.tumblr.com Twitter: @ryanfelton13 xxxEND_PAGE:deq04_b015_0647_0780_002 Pursuant to the state Freedom of Information Act (MCL 15.231 et. seq.) I request access to and copies of the following: e Any and all communications that pertain to the quarterly test results from December 2014 of the water in the City of Flint between any and all employees of the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality that were made between Dec. 1, 2014 and Jan. 1, 2015; e@ Any and all records dated between Dec. 1, 2014 and Jan. 1 2014 that pertain to the routine quarterly testing of water in the city of Flint that was conducted in December 2014. For the purposes of this request, “records” should include information of any kind, including letters, memoranda, notes, applications, completed forms, studies, reports, reviews, guidance documents, policies, documents, databases, drawings, graphs, charts, photographs, minutes of meetings, electronic and magnetic recordings of meetings. In addition, “communications” should include any correspondence, telephone conversations, telefaxes, and emails -- as well as any other compilation of data from which information can be obtained. Without limitation, the records requested include records at any stage of development, whether proposed, draft, pending, interim, final or otherwise. All such records are included in this request if they are in the possession of or otherwise under the control of the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality. In order to help to determine my status for purposes of determining the applicability of any fees, you should know that I am a journalist with the Guardian, and this request is made as part of news gathering and not for commercial use. T understand that a fee will be assessed for copies of public records in the amount prescribed under state law. I am willing to pay fees for this request up to a maximum of $100. If you estimate that the fees will exceed this limit, please inform me first. Fees must be limited to the actual costs of labor and copying, and the means for copying must be the most economical available, pursuant to MCI 15.234(1) and (3). Fees may only be assessed based on procedures and guidelines published by the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality. Also, I request a waiver of all fees for this request. Disclosure of the requested information to me is in the public interest because it is likely to contribute significantly to public understanding of the operations or activities of the government and is not primarily in my commercial interest. Should you decide to invoke a FOIA exemption, or any other exemption under statute, as the basis for withholding any record responsive to this request, please include in your full or partial denial letter sufficient information for me to appeal the denial pursuant to MCL 15.235(4)(a). To comply with legal requirements, the following information must be included: xxxEND_PAGE:deq04_b015_0647_0780_003 e Basic factual material about each withheld item, including the originator, date, length, subject matter, and location of each item; and e Explanations and justifications for denial, including the identification of the category within the governing statutory provision under which the documents (or portion thereof) was withheld and a full explanation of how each exemption fits the withheld material. If you determine that portions of a record requested are exempt from disclosure, please redact the exempt portions and provide the remainder of the record to me. T also request that records be provided in electronic format wherever possible, including but not limited to records that are stored or maintained, so as to reduce and avoid labor and printing costs related to photocopying records. I will provide a media storage device for the records at my expense. Further, I understand that under state law, the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality has five (5) business days to respond to this request, and may issue a notice extending the time for ten (10) additional business days. Please produce the requested records on a rolling basis; at no point should the search for — or deliberation concerning — certain records delay the production of other documents. Tf you find this request is unclear, please contact me immediately so I can clarify the request to simplify your compliance efforts. Thank you for your assistance. Sincerely, Ryan Felton (734) 353-2221 [email protected] xxxEND_PAGE:deq04_b015_0647_0780_004 Prysby, Mike (DEQ)

Re: Confirm details of teleconference?

Hi all, Noticed a response was passed along to Michigan Radio, in which MDEQ says lime softening has been used as a corrosion control agent "all along." Is that accurate? If so, does "all along" mean ever since Flint switched to the Flint River? Thanks. Hi David, et. al: DEQ's Wyant said this afternoon the city used corrosion controls to treat the water post-switch from DWSD. Can you tell me what agents were used, and when? Thanks much, Ryan On Fri, Oct 2, 2015 at 1:45 PM, Murray, David (GOV) <MurravD1@ It was a small group given the time limits we were facing. Will be sure to keep you in mind. Sent from my iPhone On Oct 2, 2015, at 1:44 PM, Ryan Felton <ryanti

Re: Confirm details of teleconference?

Hi David, et. al: DEQ's Wyant said this afternoon the city used corrosion controls to treat the water post-switch from DWSD. Can you tell me what agents were used, and when? Thanks much, Ryan cE Se Tt was a a small group given the time limits we were facing. Will be sure to keep you in mind. Sent from my iPhone On Oct 2, 2015, at 1:44 PM, Ryan Felton <ryanfelton | 3@amail com>>

Re: Confirm details of teleconference?

To
Unknown recipient
OK. Would appreciate any notification of such a conference call in the future. Thanks much! On Fri, Oct 2, 2015 at 1:40 PM, Murray, David (GOV) <MurrayD> | @imichigan. gov<mailto:MurrayD Il @michigan gov>> wrote: Reconnecting is an option that the city can consider. Sent from my iPhone On ‘Oct 2, 2015, at 1: 32 PM, a Felton z elton i@emai Hi David, I wanted to see if you could confirm reported details of the teleconference call this morning, in that Flint might reconnect with Detroit water? Additionally, was this a call open to the media? It would've been nice to be on that call. Best, Ryan Felton Journalist Detroit, MI 734,353 222 1<tel:734.353 > ryanfelton. tumblr.com<hit vantelion tumbl Twitter: @ryanfelton13 ryanfelion tumbir.com> m><hitn xxxEND_PAGE:executiveofficeemails20_b0961_2582_2583_1 Ryan Felton Journalist Detroit, MI 734,383 2221 ryanfelion tumblr. com> Twitter: @ryanfelton13 Ryan Felton Journalist Detroit, MI 734.353.2221 ryanfelion tumbir com Twitter: @ryanfelton13 xxxEND_PAGE:executiveofficeemails20_b0961_2582_2583_2

Confirm details of teleconference?

Hi David, I wanted to see if you could confirm reported details of the teleconference call this morning, in that Flint might reconnect with Detroit water? Additionally, was this a call open to the media? It would've been nice to be on that call. Best, Ryan Felton Journalist Detroit, MI 734.353.2221 Twitter: @ryanfelton13 xxxEND_PAGE:executiveofficeemails20_b0958_2579_2579_1

Re: PRESS INQUIRY | The Guardian re: Flint

Hello Ryan, Gov. Snyder continues to work with Sen. Ananich and others about the concerns raised about Flint's water and the city's challenges with its infrastructure. We are working closely with federal and state agencies as well as city leaders and we expect an announcement about some additional steps later this week. Gov. Snyder believes all state residents to have access to clean, safe water. The governor and the state agencies have played a highly visible role in working with Flint city leaders with their infrastructure challenges -- and will continue to do so. We understand why people are frustrated, and also want to make sure people have accurate information and know where they can go if they have questions about their health and the water connections in their home. The health and safety of Flint residents is always the first priority, and that includes ensuring there is clean, safe drinking water -- especially for children. We're working to build upon existing state efforts to work with Flint leaders on their infrastructure needs. The state so far has provided $4.2 million in grants and restructured financing to help the city locate and fix some of the problems with its water infrastructure and add the carbon filtration system. Several state agencies continue to work with Flint leaders on their water challenges including through Mayor Walling's technical advisory board. That board includes outside experts and members will study data and offer recommendations. The Department of Environmental Quality and the Department of Health and Human Services also are testing water and working with Flint residents on issues related to what they can do if they have concerns about the pipes in their homes. It’s important to remember that the emergency manager had the final say on making the change, but did so at the strong urging of Flint city leaders. Decisions about changes to the water system were not forced upon the city. Emergency managers often try to work closely with mayors and city councils, getting recommendations from the local communities they are serving. The decision to make the switch to the Karegnondi pipeline came after an 8-1 vote by the City Council and strong endorsement by the mayor and Genesee County leaders. The move also came after a series of upgrades to Flint’s water treatment plant. It’s also important to remember that switching back to Detroit water will not necessarily have the effect that some expect. Flint has long-term challenges with its water infrastructure that need to be addressed. xxxEND_PAGE:executiveofficeemails21_b0335_0694_0696_1 Lurge you to contact Angela Minicuci at MDHHS, who can discuss how state blood test data is different than what has been reported. Dave Sent from my iPad

(No subject)

To
Unknown recipient
Hi Brad, I'm working on a story for the Guardian about the recent studies that uncovered higher levels of lead in the blood of Flint children. I wanted to see if the department could answer some questions I had. xxxEND_PAGE:deq15_b221_0641_0643_1 1. What's the department's official take on the study? Does it agree that higher levels of lead are in the city's water supply ever since it transferred from DWSD to the Flint River as its source? 2. Would you provide data that shows blood-level testing of Flint children for lead over the last few years? What does the data show, according to MDEQ? An upward or downward trend? 3. Does MDEQ believe the water in Flint is safe for residents to drink? 4. Does the department have any response to allegations that testing of lead in the city was skewered to produce favorable results, to show the city was actually in compliance with federal rules? 5. Please feel freed to add anything you believe it's pertinent to the story. Thanks much, Ryan Felton Journalist Detroit, MI 734.353.2221 ryanfelton tumblr.com Twitter: @ryanfelton13 xxxEND_PAGE:deq15_b221_0641_0643_2 Ryan Felton Journalist Detroit, MI Twitter: @ryanfelton13 Ryan Felton Journalist Detroit, MI 734.353.2221 Twitter: @ryanfelton13 xxxEND_PAGE:deq15_b221_0641_0643_3

PRESS INQUIRY | The Guardian re: Flint

Hi all, I wanted to see if the governor's office would have any response to the call from Senate minority leader Jim Ananich to have Flint reconnect with Detroit's water system. It's for a story I'm working on for the Guardian, regarding the increase in lead levels in the blood of Flint children ever since the city switched to using the Flint River. Additionally, can you confirm whether or not the governor's office backed plans from Flint's emergency manager to transfer from using DWSD to the Flint River? I'm working on a 5 pm deadline for tomorrow (9/30). I appreciate your time and look forward to the response. Best, Ryan Felton Journalist Detroit, MI Twitter: @ryanfelton13 xxxEND_PAGE:executiveofficeemails21_b0438_0901_0901_1

PRESS INQUIRY | The Guardian re: Flint

To
Unknown recipient
Hi all, I wanted to see if the governor's office would have any response to the call from Senate minority leader Jim Ananich to have Flint reconnect with Detroit's water system. It's for a story I'm working on for the Guardian, regarding the increase in lead levels in the blood of Flint children ever since the city switched to using the Flint River. Additionally, can you confirm whether or not the governor's office backed plans from Flint's emergency manager to transfer from using DWSD to the Flint River? I'm working on a 5 pm deadline for tomorrow (9/30). I appreciate your time and look forward to the response. Best, Ryan Felton Journalist Detroit, MI ryantelton. tambir.com Twitter: @ryanfelton13 Ryan Felton xxxEND_PAGE:executiveofficeemails21_b0335_0694_0696_2 Journalist Detroit, MI Twitter: @ryanfelton13 xxxEND_PAGE:executiveofficeemails21_b0335_0694_0696_3

Steven Bush comment (Metro Times)

Hi Brad, I reached out to Steven, but couldn't get in touch with him. I have an appointment at 4 p.m., so I'll be out of commission afterwards. If he can be reached, the reports I was referring to can be found here: http://www. sst/2014/O7/flimt starting to flush out di html If possible, I'd be happy to receive comments by email. I'm looking to see if there's any understanding as to what caused the discoloration. As always, I appreciate your help. Thanks, Ryan Felton Investigative Reporter, Metro Times C: 734-353-2221 O: 313-961-4060 EXT. 8019 xxxEND_PAGE:deq11_b124_0277_0277_1