People Conversations • Flint Water Crisis Public Archive

Thank you for the excellent customer service. I really appreciate your efforts and willingness to drop what you were working on to answer this question from department management. Richard Sent using OWA for iPhone

Re: SDWA Violations

From: Richard Benzie
To: Adam Rosenthal , Debbie Ostrander

Mar 17, 2015 3:10 PM

See all emails with these participants

Date: Tuesday, March 17, 2015 11:10:44 AM Thank you for the excellent customer service. I really appreciate your efforts and willingness to drop what you were working on to answer this question from department management. Richard Sent using OWA for iPhone

RE: SDWA Violations

From: Debbie Ostrander
To: Adam Rosenthal

Mar 17, 2015 3:08 PM

See all emails with these participants

Yas. ididn’t spend any thre looking at what the violations were for, since you were already responding te Richard. | generated ft frarn one of the queries in SDWIS standard reports. Were you working off of the report Kris has created?

RE: SDWA Violations

From: Adam Rosenthal
To: Debbie Ostrander

Mar 17, 2015 3:05 PM

See all emails with these participants

Looks like the total is more than what | came up with’? | think the goal is to show whoever is asking that Flint is just a blip in comparison.

RE: SDWA Violations

From: Debbie Ostrander
To: Adam Rosenthal

Mar 17, 2015 3:01 PM

See all emails with these participants

Here's what E finally came un with.

RE: SDWA Violations

From: Adam Rosenthal
To: Richard Benzie , Debbie Ostrander

Mar 17, 2015 2:58 PM

See all emails with these participants

326 supplies with violations in’13 & ‘14 Flint has 5 violations in those 2 yrs - TTHM MCLs at 2 sites & 2 bacti MCLs (1 with e.coli that counts as 2)

RE: SDWA Violations

From: Adam Rosenthal
To: Richard Benzie , Debbie Ostrander

Mar 17, 2015 2:58 PM

See all emails with these participants

Date: Tuesday, March 17, 2015 10:58:09 AM 326 supplies with violations in 13 & ‘14 Flint has 5 violations in those 2 yrs - TTHM MCLs at 2 sites & 2 bacti MCLs (1 with e.coli that counts as 2)

RE: SDWA Violations

From: Adam Rosenthal
To: Richard Benzie , Debbie Ostrander

Mar 17, 2015 2:58 PM

See all emails with these participants

Date: Tuesday, March 17, 2015 10:58:10 AM 326 supplies with violations in 13 & ‘14 Flint has 5 violations in those 2 yrs - TTHM MCLs at 2 sites & 2 bacti MCLs (1 with e.coli that counts as 2)

RE: SDWA Violations

From: Adam Rosenthal
To: Richard Benzie , Debbie Ostrander

Mar 17, 2015 2:25 PM

See all emails with these participants

For the majority yes, an E.coli MCL counts as 2. | will work on your ofher questions. Adam

Re: SDWA Violations

From: Richard Benzie
To: Adam Rosenthal , Debbie Ostrander

Mar 17, 2015 2:22 PM

See all emails with these participants

Date: Tuesday, March 17, 2015 10:22:28 AM Do I understand that the multiple violations are probably all monitoring violations? If so, I won't worry about lumping them together. Is there a way to separate out the number of systems that had these 1200 violations? At the very least we need to be able to show how Flint fits in - what are there numbers over those two years? Sent using OWA for iPhone

Re: SDWA Violations

From: Richard Benzie
To: Adam Rosenthal , Debbie Ostrander

Mar 17, 2015 2:21 PM

See all emails with these participants

Do | understand that the multiple violations are probably all monitoring violations? If so, I won't worry about lumping them together. Is there a way to separate out the number of systems that had these 1200 violations? At the very least we need to be able to show how Flint fits in - what are there numbers over those two years? Sent using OWA for iPhone

RE: SDWA Violations

From: Adam Rosenthal
To: Richard Benzie , Debbie Ostrander

Mar 17, 2015 2:13 PM

See all emails with these participants

So far it shows 1110 violations for calendar 13 & ‘14. 200 are MCL, which leaves 910 other violations. However, there are many violations we would count as 1 that SDWIS counts as more, ie. a system fails to collect DBP — that is 2 or more violations. A VOC MV counts as 20 violations in SDWIS, etc. What would you like to do? Adam

RE: SDWA Violations

From: Adam Rosenthal
To: Richard Benzie , Debbie Ostrander

Mar 17, 2015 2:11 PM

See all emails with these participants

So far it shows 1110 violations for calendar 13 & ‘14. 200 are MCL, which leaves 910 other violations. However, there are many violations we would count as 1 that SOWIS counts as more, ie. a system fails to collect DBP — that is 2 or more violations. AVOC MV counts as 20 violations in SDWIS, etc. What would you like to do? Adam

RE: SDWA Violations

From: Richard Benzie
To: Adam Rosenthal , Debbie Ostrander

Mar 16, 2015 8:13 PM

See all emails with these participants

Calendar. Thanks. i think they want ft to show someone that Flint is not alone in having violations.

RE: SDWA Violations

From: Adam Rosenthal
To: Richard Benzie , Debbie Ostrander

Mar 16, 2015 8:11 PM

See all emails with these participants

| can take a look, calendar or fiscal? Adam

SDWA Violations

From: Richard Benzie
To: Debbie Ostrander , Adam Rosenthal

Mar 16, 2015 8:05 PM

See all emails with these participants

| need someone to provide a list or summary of the violations that have occurred in 2013 and 2014. Kris is out until Thursday, maybe Friday and Jean is still out for a few weeks. It may be as simple as running a standard report, but it’s easier for me to ask you than to figure that out right now. | thought of you two, as the SDWIS back-up (Deb) and someone Kris tells me is more savvy in manipulating databases than one may realize (Adam). Could either of you provide some sort of report on the statewide violations for the past 2 calendar years? The request from upstairs wants all violations, but | think it would be beneficial to at least say what portion are monitoring violations and what portion are MCL and other violations. Let me know if you can or cannot meet this request. Thanks, xxxEND_PAGE:deq21_b458_1245_1246_1 Richard xxxEND_PAGE:deq21_b458_1245_1246_2