Rita Bair

Region 5 Groundwater and Drinking Water Branch Supervisor at EPA Groundwater and Drinking Water Branch / EPA

9

Emails

Nov 2014–Sep 2015

Archive range

9 emails found.

FW: Flint Ml: LCR Enforcement Issues

Hi Tom, Nick, and Rita -- | will set up a meeting to discuss this email. Let me know if you would like me to include HQ. Thanks! Best wishes, Heather Heather A. Shoven | Enforcement Team Leader | U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Region 5 Ground Water and Drinking Water Branch | 77 W. Jackson Blvd (WG-15J) | Chicago, IL 60604 | 312-886-0153

Reporter inquiry

Just FYI - I had a voicemail from Jessica Dupnack (a reporter in MJ) regarding the Walters’ sample results and I forwarded it to Pete Cassell as requested. Miguel A. Del Toral Regulations Manager U.S. EPA RS GWDWB xxxEND_PAGE:deq03_b604_2838_3252_275 77 West Jackson Blvd, (WG-15J) Chicago, IL 60604 Phone: (312) 886-5253 xxxEND_PAGE:deq03_b604_2838_3252_276 Rennaker, Joanne (DEQ)

RE: Flint Water Question from a Pregnant Flint Resident

Hi Rita, Thank you very much for your detailed response. It is helpful and I appreciate it greatly. All the best, Mona _ We are responding to your email of July 11, 2015 to Miguel Del Toral. He is out of the office today, but has _ provided the following information to your lead questions. Overall, he agrees with Marc’s responses on the | water filter. Filters that are certified to remove lead are typically designed to remove 99 percent of the | lead. They are also designed with additional capacity as a safety measure, but you should still change the filter in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions. If you identify elevated lead levels from other taps that do - not have water filters, we suggest either adding a filter to those, such as the bathroom tap, or only using the | filtered tap water for consumption. xxxEND_PAGE:deq21_b081_0253_0257_1 _ If you are still interested in having your water tested you should use a laboratory that has been certified by the | State for drinking water E enailyaes (a list i is swuilable from the anne link: : i é OG html. Please note that a first-draw - sample, emer of pre- flushing, is best for identifying lead that comes from the faucet and other in-home ' piping or fittings close to the faucet. First-draw sampling does not give a good indication of the lead - contribution from sources further from the faucet (i.e. lead service line, leaded brass meter, etc.). Information | for residents about first-draw samuling bi instructions can be found on the last page of ‘he 2006 memo on aerators | aerators 10202006. pdf In addition, bela are two Panne — our Region 5 “meat ort information - about how to identify if you have a lead service line coming into your home and for faucets that do not have | filters on them, how to clean the aerators. - Regarding your TTHM question, EPA has considered developmental and reproductive risks from multiple _ intake routes of exposure (e.g., ingestion, inhalation, and dermal) in our 2006 Disinfectants and Disinfection ' Byproducts (DBPR) rule. Some studies did suggest associations between TTHM exposure and various adverse - reproductive and development health effects. However, studies available overall showed inconsistent _ results. As such, our Agency could not conclude whether exposure to TTHMs could cause adverse _ health effects. However, we did note in our findings that there was the potential | for concern. - Currently, we are in the process of re-evaluating our DBPR rules and considering new toxicological data _ regarding reproductive and developmental health effects. Until our evaluation is complete, pregnant women - can elect to take additional precautionary measures such as taking shorter showers, venting the room while | showering/bathing, and not ingesting water with high TTHM concentrations. | We hope this information is helpful to you. Rita D. Bair : Section 2 Chief : Ground Water and Drinking Water Branch USEPA-Region 5 : phone: | fax: 312-692-2132 xxxEND_PAGE:deq21_b081_0253_0257_2 Lead service lines are generally a dull gray color and are very soft. You can identify them easily ay carefully scratching weak a hey, lf the pipe is rnade af lead, the area you've scratched will ture = beragit sibeer color. Da nat use a knife or other sharp instrument and take care not to puncture a hole in the pine. Ea Bees Le Lead sereire lines can be connected te the residential plumbing usag solder and have a characteristic solder “bulb” at the end, a compression fitting, ar other conmecter made of galvanized iron or brass/ bronze. MBter, YOu water wet? may be in your hame a Lead service lines often end dust inside the frant or side wall of the home, bur may extend further into the “meter pit” or “meter «i @s shwwn above. building as shown, where the Jead service line comes gut af the basement flanr te the water meter and then back into the floor, continuing Farther mto the building. i Sica ema ea : Ee EU eee eee ee Ee _-=Ssiésizs_i_C = eee i: __sazéwétié#iz. iMany taps have an aereter as part of the faucet assembly. Aerator screens are not intended to remove contaminants in: water, but may trap sediment or debris as water passes through the faucet. Lead-bearing sediment may end up in drin water from physical corresiom of leaded solder and can build up in the aerator over time. t. Remove the aerator by peisting off with hands or pliers. 2. Qae oy more parts are contained within the aerator. Mate the arder anc orientation of the parts as you remave them. 3. Rinse the pieces with weter and Orush aff the 4, Reassemble the ser screw it back onte the and hancd-tighten. if ar debris, For deposits that ace difficult ta remove, soak the parts in water for a few sinutes and scrub with a toothbrush, Backwashing parts are cracked or broken, repiace them. washer has hardened should be replaced. Berator campanents is also en effective cdeaning method for many aerator types. Hold the removed aerator uoside down under flowing water ta bechwash screens and mesh filters. xxxEND_PAGE:deq21_b081_0253_0257_3 _ From: Mona Munroe-Younis [mailto: _ Sent: Saturday, July 11, 2015 5:57 P ai

RE: Flint Water Question from a Pregnant Flint Resident

To
Unknown recipient
| We are responding to your email of July 11, 2015 to Miguel Del Toral. He is out of the office today, but has _ provided the following information to your lead questions. Overall, he agrees with Marc’s responses on the _ water filter. Filters that are certified to remove lead are typically designed to remove 99 percent of the _ lead. They are also designed with additional capacity as a safety measure, but you should still change the filter _ in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions. If you identify elevated lead levels from other taps that do _ not have water filters, we suggest either adding a filter to those, such as the bathroom tap, or only using the | filtered tap water for consumption. xxxEND_PAGE:deq18_b042_0953_0958_1 | If you are still interested in having your water tested you should use a laboratory that has been certified by the State for drinking water analyses (a list is available from the following link: /iwwen Inichican. ¢ i GOLhimd. Please note that a first-draw - sample, regardless of p pre- -flushing, is best for identifying lead that comes from the faucet and other in-home _ piping or fittings close to the faucet. First-draw sampling does not give a good indication of the lead - contribution from sources further from the faucet (i.e. lead service line, leaded brass meter, etc.). Information _ for residents about first-draw Satya instructions can be found 0 on ar last page of the 2006 memo on aerators aerators 10202006.pdf In addition, below are two sophia from our Region 5 website with freeman _ about how to identify if you have a lead service line coming into your home and for faucets that do not have _ filters on them, how to clean the aerators. ' Regarding your TTHM question, EPA has considered developmental and reproductive risks from multiple _ intake routes of exposure (e.g., ingestion, inhalation, and dermal) in our 2006 Disinfectants and Disinfection - Byproducts (DBPR) rule. Some studies did suggest associations between TTHM exposure and various adverse _ reproductive and development health effects. However, studies available overall showed inconsistent _ results. As such, our Agency could not conclude whether exposure to TTHMs could cause adverse _ health effects. However, we did note in our findings that there was the potential _ for concern. | Currently, we are in the process of re-evaluating our DBPR tules and considering new toxicological data | regarding reproductive and developmental health effects. Until our evaluation is complete, pregnant women - can elect to take additional precautionary measures such as taking shorter showers, venting the room while _ showering/bathing, and not ingesting water with high TTHM concentrations. | We hope this information is helpful to you. : Rita D. Bair : Section 2 Chief : Ground Water and Drinking Water Branch USEPA-Region 5 - phone: : fax: 312-692-2432 xxxEND_PAGE:deq18_b042_0953_0958_2 Lead service lines are generally a dull gray color mod are very soft. You can identify thera easihy by carefully scratching vith x key. Hthe pine is made of lead, the area you've scratched will turn a bright silver color. Do not ase ia knife or other shara mstrument and take care not to punchere « hole in the PSE, coe Lead service Hines can be camected to the residential plumbing using sakder and have a characteristic coicter “bulb” at the end, a comoression fitting, or other ganmecter made of galvanized iron or brass {hronze. iW your home hes a wat meter, your water met Rey be in your home o Lead service ines aften end “meter pit® or "meter ve gust inside the front ar cide wall of the hame, but may extend firther ita the ae shown abowe. building as shawn, where the lead service line comes out of the basernert floor ta the water meter and then back into the Foor, continuing further into the budding. xxxEND_PAGE:deq18_b042_0953_0958_3 Le eae Eee Bee nd ee i. any taps have an aerator as part of the faucet assembly. Aerator screens are not intended to cemove contaminants in water, but may trap sediment or debris as water passes thraugh the faucet. Lead-bearing sediment may end up in drin water from chysical corrosion of leaded salder and can build up in the aerator over time. 1. Remove the aerator by 3 - ‘ea i“ 2. Rinse the pieces wit! ae imeck ovithin th - water and brush off the ves ° : phars. contained within the aerator. 4 Rosscomblietiecme twisting off with hands or 2. One or more parts are debris. For deposits that are difficult te remove, soak the parts in water for a few Note the order anc orfentation of the parts as screw it back onte the and hand-tghten. ff ar you remove them. parts are cracked or broken, reaiace them. washer hac hardened should be replaced. oinutes and scrub with a teothbrush. Bachwashing Berator components & alsa en effective cleaning method for many aerator types. Hale the removed serator upside down under Sowing water to backwash screens and raesh filters.

FYI: Water Dilemma in Flint

A Water Dilemma in or Costly? By MITCH SMITHMARCH 24, 2015 chigan: Cloudy Vernon White over the Flint River, which replaced Lake Huron as the water source in Flirt, Mich, Mr. White says fe buys soda fo avoid the water. FLINT, Mich. — Depending on the day, Melissa Mays says, the water flowing out of her home’s faucets might have a blue tint. Or it might smell like mothballs. Or it might fill her home with the scent of an overchiarinated swimrning pool. Lately, Ms. Mays, who is 36 and works in marketing, has not been turning on her tap much at all, After Flint changed the source of its drinking water last spring, Ms. Mays said, she noticed a change in the water’s color and odor. Then she started having rashes, and clumps of her hair fell out. When the city issued @ boll order, she stopped using the water for drinking and cooking. Now her family spends roughly $400 a month on bottled water. xxxEND_PAGE:deq21_b459_1247_1249_1 “My cat gets bottled water, our glants aet bottled water, our fish gets bottled water,” sald Ms. Mays, who has helped organize marches to protest the water conditions and is on a city commission seeking input on how to move forward. “It takes four to five botties of water to fill up a pot for spaghetti.” Flint officiais insist that the city’s water is safe. They say that the issues of odor and color are sanarate